Friday, April 01, 2005

Reactionary Liberals

Here is a pretty convincing argument that, for many Democrats, there position on the recent "right to die" debate was driven not by principle but by reactionary politics:
Their passionate conviction that Terri must die cannot be explained in terms of any recognizable liberal perspective, whether a disbelief in the soul, the desire to dispense with a less-than-complete human life that inconveniences others, a devotion to serving the rights and desires of individuals, or an easy-going attitude toward the traditional bonds and duties of marriage. Therefore, I would argue, their position on the Schiavo case can only be explained as stemming from something extrinsic to the case itself, namely their bigoted animus against conservatives: since conservatives support Terri Schiavo's right to live, liberals must oppose it. As a liberal professor recently said to an acquaintance of mine (and these were his exact words), "Anything Tom DeLay and those conservatives are for, I'm against."
You can't have much of a debate with that thought process.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home